Page 1 of 2

The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 5:03 am
by math_applicant
Since April 15th is closing in with many of us waiting to hear from some schools (waitlisted or second round offers) (including myself) and equally many with a few admits in hand to choose from and haven't made their minds yet (including myself), I thought of starting a thread to help both groups. People who are still not sure about their choice of one school vs another can post their particular question here so they can get feedback from others and thus help them get to their decisions sooner. This will also help those who are waitlisted by the same schools get their answer sooner as well.

My particular question was posted here: http://www.mathematicsgre.com/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=1228 . I got some pretty helpful insights, and I welcome anyone who has to add to the points made there.

Good luck for everyone!

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 8:14 am
by selcuk2459
I have a very similar situation. There is only one school left for me. I am not waitlisted but did not get an offer nor rejection. There is another school whose offer I am preparing to accept but since they (illinois chicago) dont tell me anything, I am waiting and still can not sleep at nights. At least they can tell me that I have zero chance and no need to wait.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 8:51 am
by marco
This is a great idea. I guess we could start by stating the schools we have been accepted to and the schools we are waiting on.
My list is the following:
Accepted: University of Arizona.
Waiting on:
Duke University
University of Maryland-College Park-AMSC program
University of Minnesota
New York University.

My research direction is Applied Math probably Applied Stochastic Analysis.

I guess maybe we could start by stating the information that we know of the admissions process of the various schools that people are waiting for.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 9:03 am
by coral
+ stating if you are pure/applied/stats/OR might be helpful (at least for people like me who aren't on here too often and so don't remember what everyone is doing). Also research direction if you know.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 9:08 am
by selcuk2459
mine is pure math. out of 10 i heard from northwestern, texas a&m, stony brook, louisiana state, u washington, rutgers; florida state, u of miami and tulane. the first 6 are rejections and others acceptances. illinois chicago no news.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 9:19 am
by math_applicant
So I guess to sum up, people who have heard from the following schools and are have yet to make up their minds, please share your thoughts so we can help you with your decision. This will help you and others waiting as well.

Applied Math (marco):
Duke University
University of Maryland-College Park
University of Minnesota
New York University.

Pure Math:
Illinois-Chicago (selcuk2459).
UIUC (myself).
Duke (myself).

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 9:42 am
by coral
marco, I have an offer from Maryland that I'm likely to decline. I'm going to keep an open mind at visiting weekend this weekend but based on academic interest I think another school is a better fit for me. I'll let the know as soon as visiting weekend is over so I hope you get an offer. I hear that they are very strong in pde dynamical system stuff and what you are interested in as well.

Also haven't heard from nyu here either, and can't help you with the other schools.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 10:00 am
by marco
coral wrote:marco, I have an offer from Maryland that I'm likely to decline. I'm going to keep an open mind at visiting weekend this weekend but based on academic interest I think another school is a better fit for me. I'll let the know as soon as visiting weekend is over so I hope you get an offer. I hear that they are very strong in pde dynamical system stuff and what you are interested in as well.

Also haven't heard from nyu here either, and can't help you with the other schools.
Hey Coral thanks a lot for letting me know about this. I'm really happy to hear it. BTW I applied to the AMSC program (Applied Math) which is separate from the pure math program. Where did you apply to? Congratulations by the way on your admits!

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 11:01 am
by meredith
Hey!

I'm wait listed at Washington University. Does anyone have an offer from them that they're planning to decline?

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 11:07 am
by tbil
Trying to decide between an unknown, lowly ranked school (in the top 100, but barely) where I've already made a connection with a potential advisor who is eager to work with me and is doing research that interests me...

-or-

Rice CAAM. I don't know anyone there. I've never visited. But many of the professors there do research that I'm interested in, too.


I suppose the obvious choice is Rice... but I feel sad about having to say no to the first school, where when I went to visit the campus they were so kind to me and eager to have me come. I hate disappointing people! :(

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 11:14 am
by meredith
tbil wrote:I suppose the obvious choice is Rice... but I feel sad about having to say no to the first school, where when I went to visit the campus they were so kind to me and eager to have me come. I hate disappointing people! :(
I know exactly how you feel! I've chatted with a couple of people at ASU and I feel bad turning down the offer.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 11:22 am
by math_applicant
@tbil: I am sure professors will understand your position in turning down their offer, I don't think there will be any disappointment, PhD is a big decision, it's a place where you will spend may be over 5 years and will decide a lot about your career afterwards, so I think you should go to the best place you got into.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 11:24 am
by math_applicant
Summary:
math_applicant wrote:
Applied Math (marco):
Duke University
University of Maryland-College Park
University of Minnesota
New York University.

Pure Math:
Illinois-Chicago (selcuk2459).
UIUC (myself).
Duke (myself).
Adding Washington university.

@meredith, could you indicate your area of interest (applied vs pure)?

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 11:27 am
by coral
marco, I also applied to amsc, so same program. :)

tbil, yeah I hate that too, especially if they paid for you to visit and everything... Have you asked the advisor for his/her opinion? I've actually had advisors from one school be very honest and recommend me to go to another school that they thought had a stronger program.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 11:33 am
by Langlands
I've not been rejected from Boston College (pure). I was told a first round of acceptances had been sent out and that I'd be notified if any progress was made with my application. Its a small program (~5 admits a year) so I'm thinking the wait list is relatively short.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 11:39 am
by math_applicant
coral wrote: I've actually had advisors from one school be very honest and recommend me to go to another school that they thought had a stronger program.
How did you frame your request for advice ? I am not sure about how to ask one professor at a certain department whether he thinks their group is strong enough.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 12:09 pm
by meredith
I'm doing pure math.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 12:11 pm
by coral
math_applicant wrote:
coral wrote: I've actually had advisors from one school be very honest and recommend me to go to another school that they thought had a stronger program.
How did you frame your request for advice ? I am not sure about how to ask one professor at a certain department whether he thinks their group is strong enough.
So I didn't frame it in terms of there program not being strong enough, but instead I told him, "in addition to the program here, I'm also considering XXX. I'm interested in XXX. I'm wondering what your thoughts are on their department and their research strength in this area."

One professor told me that he had actually collaborated with people in the other department and that he has only good things to say about them. Another said that the other department is slightly stronger in XXX-subarea and if he were me all things being equal he would have a slight preference for the other department. Of course he following up with other positive things to consider about his own department but I think overall professors are pretty honest and will understand if you made a choice based on academic strength.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 12:19 pm
by marco
coral wrote:marco, I also applied to amsc, so same program. :)

tbil, yeah I hate that too, especially if they paid for you to visit and everything... Have you asked the advisor for his/her opinion? I've actually had advisors from one school be very honest and recommend me to go to another school that they thought had a stronger program.
That is definitely good to know! Thanks Coral for sharing :P !

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 12:21 pm
by marco
So here is the updated list:


Applied Math (marco):
Duke University
University of Maryland-College Park-AMSC
University of Minnesota
New York University.

Pure Math:
Illinois-Chicago (selcuk2459).
UIUC (myself).
Duke (myself).
University of Washington in St Louis (meredith).

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 12:44 pm
by meredith
marco wrote:So here is the updated list:


Applied Math (marco):
Duke University
University of Maryland-College Park-AMSC
University of Minnesota
New York University.

Pure Math:
Illinois-Chicago (selcuk2459).
UIUC (myself).
Duke (myself).
University of Washington (meredith).

I'm actually Washington University in St. Louis

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 12:45 pm
by marco
Sorry about that. I have corrected the updated list.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 7:00 pm
by rmg512
Still waiting on Purdue Pure Math. My top choice at the moment... Given OSU is paying me $500 if I accept their offer by April 1st, I'm going to be pissed if Purdue rejects me after April 1st...

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 7:06 pm
by meredith
rmg512 wrote:OSU is paying me $500 if I accept their offer by April 1st
Holy crap! That is the smartest thing ever. Would definitely speed this whole process along if more schools did something like that.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 11:14 pm
by farmhouse
@Marco

Have you heard about funding for the applied math program at Arizona?

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 11:42 pm
by ApplMathProfile
Edited

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 11:47 pm
by cooltrainer
ApplMathProfile wrote:To help people out (all of these are for Applied Math):

Accepted:
Northwestern (ESAM)
NYU (Atmosphere+Ocean Science)
UIC
Purdue

Waiting on:
Michigan (AIM)
Maryland (AMSC)

Rejected from:
Caltech (ACM)
Washington-Seattle
UChicago

I am officially waitisted form Michigan, but I haven't heard from Maryland since the request for more information.
Wow, this looks really impressive.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 11:51 pm
by coral
ApplMathProfile, the michigan AIM program received ~150 applications, they have made about a dozen acceptances, and are hoping for an incoming class of about 6 or 7. I was talking to some students and at least 2 will be declining, so if you are keen to go there, you've got chances. And of course, congrats on your acceptances. :)

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 21, 2013 11:57 pm
by marco
farmhouse wrote:@Marco

Have you heard about funding for the applied math program at Arizona?
Hello I have heard on funding but I got into the Pure Math program :P .

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Fri Mar 22, 2013 12:08 am
by farmhouse
marco wrote:
farmhouse wrote:@Marco

Have you heard about funding for the applied math program at Arizona?
Hello I have heard on funding but I got into the Pure Math program :P .
Thanks! I'm hoping to hear from them soon.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Fri Mar 22, 2013 12:10 am
by ApplMathProfile
Edited

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Fri Mar 22, 2013 12:19 am
by MathFreaked
farmhouse wrote:
marco wrote:
farmhouse wrote:@Marco

Have you heard about funding for the applied math program at Arizona?
Hello I have heard on funding but I got into the Pure Math program :P .
Thanks! I'm hoping to hear from them soon.
I haven't heard anything on Arizona (applied math) funding yet, other than a message on 03.08.13 saying that I was being "strongly considered for funding" or something to that effect.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Fri Mar 22, 2013 12:21 am
by MathFreaked
ApplMathProfile wrote:... I know Northwestern also got ~150 applications and accepted about a dozen. Not sure if they're waitlisting or not.
As someone currently on the waitlist, they definitely have one (or so they tell me). I was told they sent out ~12 acceptances and have ~8 of us on the "reserves list".

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Fri Mar 22, 2013 12:22 am
by cooltrainer
:)

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Fri Mar 22, 2013 12:28 am
by farmhouse
MathFreaked wrote:
I haven't heard anything on Arizona (applied math) funding yet, other than a message on 03.08.13 saying that I was being "strongly considered for funding" or something to that effect.
That's good to know. I got a similar message on the same day.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Fri Mar 22, 2013 4:38 am
by math_applicant
Anyone else out there still confused about the choices they have blocking their decision ? The saga isn't complete with the waitlisted only :D the thread has the names of the schools being waited for, if someone out there has NOT made their mind yet regarding these schools, you could let us know what is blocking you so we can help.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Fri Mar 22, 2013 4:46 am
by math_applicant
ApplMathProfile wrote: Thanks, that's good to know! I am still interested in Michigan since I love Ann Arbor, but if I get in and they don't blow me away during the visit, I'll probably go to NYU or Northwestern (visited both and loved them). My decision depends on whether I want to do atmospheric research vs. engineering research.
Could you post the issues blocking your choice between NYU and Northwestern ? may be someone can help you out!

Also, If you don't mind me noticing that your choice is restricted to NYU, Northwestern while waiting on Michigan, Does that mean you already declined Purdue and UIC or not yet ? If not, you could also ask for help with such decision.

congrats on the admits and good luck hearing from Michigan.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Fri Mar 22, 2013 5:25 am
by Gasquet
Wait-list:
UCLA (online status still says no decision made. Email exchange told me wait-list)
UMN

Not heard from:
UIC
NYU
Stony Brook AMS
Maryland AMSC (didn't get the further questions).

All applied math.

Anyone who has got admits from any of these schools and does not intend to go there, please decline soon so that I may get out of this limbo.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Fri Mar 22, 2013 9:06 am
by marco
[/quote]I haven't heard anything on Arizona (applied math) funding yet, other than a message on 03.08.13 saying that I was being "strongly considered for funding" or something to that effect.[/quote]

March 8 was the date they told me financial decisions were made for the pure math program. So I'm guessing there could be another date for the financial decisions on the applied math program to be made.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Fri Mar 22, 2013 10:55 am
by math_applicant
rmg512 wrote:Still waiting on Purdue Pure Math. My top choice at the moment... Given OSU is paying me $500 if I accept their offer by April 1st, I'm going to be pissed if Purdue rejects me after April 1st...
I have the same problem with UIUC, I am waitlisted there and they are having their open house around the end of March so I suppose I won't hear from them before April 1st either. It would really suck to get a rejection later and pass on the bonus at the same time.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Sat Mar 23, 2013 12:09 pm
by marco
So suppose I wanted to send an email to a school asking about my application status? Would you guys think it is a good idea to
tell them that I have been admitted to another program but I am waiting for a decision from them because they are one of my top choices? Would it be a good idea to mention the name of the school?

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Sat Mar 23, 2013 12:18 pm
by meredith
marco wrote:So suppose I wanted to send an email to a school asking about my application status? Would you guys think it is a good idea to
tell them that I have been admitted to another program but I am waiting for a decision from them because they are one of my top choices? Would it be a good idea to mention the name of the school?
When I emailed, I said something along the lines of "I'm very interested in your school, but I have other schools waiting on my decision. I understand that you're very busy, but any information you can give me on the status of my application would be greatly appreciated"

I'm actually trying to stay strong and not email WashU again until April, but it's getting tough.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Sat Mar 23, 2013 12:26 pm
by MathFreaked
marco wrote:So suppose I wanted to send an email to a school asking about my application status? Would you guys think it is a good idea to
tell them that I have been admitted to another program but I am waiting for a decision from them because they are one of my top choices? Would it be a good idea to mention the name of the school?
This is purely anecdotal evidence, but I did this about a week ago as I was frustrated that I hadn't heard back from 3 schools yet. I didn't mention any of my acceptances in particular, I just said that I had some and was hoping to have more time to make an educated decision. I heard back from all 3 schools I contacted, 1 of which accepted me (officially), 1 of which rejected me (unofficially), and 1 of which told me that a decision would be made on my application "soon" (which I interpreted as April 15th).

All in all I'd say it can't hurt to ask, unless the school specifically asks you not to (e.g. I saw a post somewhere on this site recently linking to Rice's FAQ that tells candidates not to email the department with questions about application status).

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Sat Mar 23, 2013 12:28 pm
by marco
meredith wrote:
marco wrote:So suppose I wanted to send an email to a school asking about my application status? Would you guys think it is a good idea to
tell them that I have been admitted to another program but I am waiting for a decision from them because they are one of my top choices? Would it be a good idea to mention the name of the school?
When I emailed, I said something along the lines of "I'm very interested in your school, but I have other schools waiting on my decision. I understand that you're very busy, but any information you can give me on the status of my application would be greatly appreciated"

I'm actually trying to stay strong and not email WashU again until April, but it's getting tough.
Im going to go ahead and mail one school in particular :P . I won't mention the school I have got into. I'll keep you posted.
Thanks for your advice.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Sat Mar 23, 2013 12:41 pm
by marco
Message sent.

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Mon Mar 25, 2013 2:07 pm
by marco
So I received a reply from UMN regarding my application status. Basically they wait-listed me, they said that I was on the alternate list and that if I was still interested by April 8 I should email them. They said that on April 8 they may or may not make a second round of offers, depending on the replies they receive from the first round.
BTW has anyone heard from NYU?

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Wed Mar 27, 2013 6:22 pm
by meredith
I just got an acceptance letter from Washington University in St. Louis! Very excited!

However, now it's decision time. Do people know anything about the department (from a visit or something)?

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 28, 2013 1:03 am
by marco
Congrats! It's good to know people do actually get off the waitlist!

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Thu Mar 28, 2013 1:59 am
by meredith
:) Thanks marco! I really hope things work out for you!

Re: The Saga of the Confused and the Waitlisted!

Posted: Fri Mar 29, 2013 9:58 am
by longtm1989
Today's almost the end of the month, hope that schools will send something. At least they should have like a reasonable list of waitlisted and accepted students at the moment.